View
← Caleb Ibejigba Case study 01 Aviva
Pensions · Deferred membersWrite-up on Substack

Enabling deferred members to restart pension contributions online

OrganisationAviva
DisciplineProduct management
SubjectDeferred pension pots
Full write-upRead on Substack →
Aviva offices
Where it started

When I left my employer, who opened a pension pot for me with Aviva, I was left with two choices: combine it with my new pension scheme or leave it.

I chose the latter, but here is the problem: I have to pay it manually; setting up a recurring payment in the Aviva app is impossible. I hate calling customer support, and to be honest, I'd rather not walk to the post office to mail a direct debit mandate. So where do we go from here?

Read the full write-up
The pitch

Let a member who has left their employer initiate recurring Direct Debit payments into their existing Aviva pension pot by extending the existing single payment flow Aviva has already created, rather than having it currently fall back to a paper mandate once money needs to be moved on an ongoing basis.

What the product does today

If a member logs in to the 'deferred' pot and goes to the pension to top it up, their only option in MyAviva is 'Make payments into your pension', which only facilitates one-off payments. There's nowhere in the app to set up regular or recurring contributions. The one-off payment takes you to a three-step form.

It asks about member status (the relief-at-source question), then employment status, amount with the tax relief being grossed up in real-time, source of the funds, followed by electronic identity and AML checks by an external provider, investment allocation (defaults to your existing allocation), and finally a comprehensive declarations page with a tick box confirmation.

After you click accept on that final step, the money still doesn't change hands. Instead, you're presented with a message that says: “send us a BACS or bank transfer for £XX to [Account number], reference number: [Plan number]. We can't action your payment until we receive it”. Credit cards are not accepted either.

  • There's no functionality for recurring contributions. To make an additional monthly contribution, the member has to go through the full single payment flow every month and complete another manual bank transfer, or contact Aviva by phone to arrange a paper Direct Debit mandate.
  • Even the single payments aren't truly digital. They only initiate the process, which the member must then complete through manual intervention with their bank, and there's always a chance of an error with the plan reference.
Current-state flow: paying into a deferred pot in MyAviva, ending in a manual BACS transfer
Current-state flow, observed in the app
Why this could be a quick build

Aviva already has the hard work of the process built for single payments. All of the compliance points required to enable a Direct Debit can be found and captured in the existing flow: the relief-at-source questions, source of funds and AML checks, ID verification, investment allocation, declarations — all exist, and they work.

The only part missing is the money transfer element: the ability to store the member's bank details, create an AUDDIS Bacs Direct Debit Instruction, and optionally set the payment frequency. The compliance requirements for a paper mandate are already satisfied digitally, so the request becomes extending what's already there, not rebuilding compliance.

Who it's for

A member with a deferred pot who wants to start contributing from their own money. These are motivated, liquid members that would be easy to retain and quick to lose through friction.

Daniel, 35, member with a deferred pot. He recently left the employer that sponsored his Aviva workplace pension, now manages the pot via the app, and is digitally savvy. Since changing jobs, he wants to continue contributing to his pension pot. He cannot initiate recurring payments from the app, so having to make manual payments each month means his initial intention to continue saving lapses over time.

As someone with a deferred Aviva pension from a previous employer, I want to set up a recurring Direct Debit from within the app, so that I can consistently save for my retirement without the hassle of monthly manual payments.

  • As a deferred member, I want to be clearly informed upfront whether my plan can accept further contributions, so I avoid dead ends.
  • As a deferred member, I want the app to remember the information I've already provided, so that I can set up regular payments efficiently.
  • As a deferred member, I want control over my contribution amount and frequency, and the flexibility to adjust or cancel it later.
The proposal

Quick win. Integrate a Direct Debit at the end of the current single-payment flow, asking the member if they want to set this up as a regular payment. This leverages existing screens and turns a one-off process into an optional recurring one, also making the one-off payment an actual pull instead of a push.

The full path. Introduce a “set up a regular payment” option in the pension's actions menu. This path would go through the existing declaration and checks, collect bank details once, and register an AUDDIS paperless Direct Debit with amount and frequency options that the member can change.

What I would actively not do. Avoid asking the member to email back a signed mandate. An email containing a signed Direct Debit mandate includes personal banking details, creating security risks, and would be rejected by Aviva's security. The aim is to avoid the mandate leaving the product altogether.

Today vs proposed
Side-by-side comparison of the member journey today and as proposed
Member journey: today versus proposed
Wireframes of the existing single-payment screens and the proposed regular-payment screens
Wireframes: the flow as it works today, and where the change goes

The key is that we're not aiming to just speed up an existing manual process, but rather removing a manual step and a missing functionality entirely by building upon what Aviva already has in place.

Effort versus impact

Positioned on a 2x2 matrix of impact versus effort, the Direct Debit collection falls into the quick win section because much of the flow already exists. The eligibility check would be the foundational element.

Impact versus effort table for each piece of work
Impact versus effort, relative judgements for prioritisation

The dedicated recurring flow represents the larger project, but will be much smaller than it appears thanks to the reusable compliance UI. Recommended phased approach: quick win including the eligibility check, then a full recurring payments flow.

How we measure a win
Chart showing where members drop off today versus the proposed flow
Illustrative drop-off: percentages show the shape, not measured data
Speed

Time taken from member intent to payment collection, in days.

Completion

The ratio of contributions initiated to actually completed.

Conversion

The percentage of single-payment users who convert to a recurring Direct Debit.

Value

The amount of recurring contributions recovered from deferred members quarterly.

Risks
  • Scheme eligibility varies. Trust-based occupational schemes may not accept further member contributions, while group personal pensions usually can. The flow checks eligibility first and routes the member.
  • Legacy administration. Some deferred pots sit on back-office systems with no self-service hook. The quick win targets pots already served by the single-payment flow, since those clearly have the infrastructure.
  • Compliance sign-off. The digital capture already stands up for single payments, so extending the same capture to a recurring mandate is building on a precedent Aviva has already accepted, not inventing a new one.
Why it's worth doing

The member has already decided to save. Every step of manual friction is a chance for that decision to unravel.

Because the compliance flow already exists, this is a rare case where a small, contained build protects retirement outcomes for the customer and recurring revenue for the business at the same time.